multi

OpenFeature Multi-Provider

[!WARNING] The multi package for the go-sdk is experimental.

The multi-provider allows you to use multiple underlying providers as sources of flag data for the OpenFeature server SDK. The multi-provider acts as a wrapper providing a unified interface to interact with all of those providers at once. When a flag is being evaluated, the Multi-Provider will consult each underlying provider it is managing in order to determine the final result. Different evaluation strategies can be defined to control which providers get evaluated and which result is used.

The multi-provider is defined within Appendix A: Included Utilities of the openfeature spec.

The multi-provider is a powerful tool for performing migrations between flag providers, or combining multiple providers into a single feature flagging interface. For example:

• Migration: When migrating between two providers, you can run both in parallel under a unified flagging interface. As flags are added to the new provider, the multi-provider will automatically find and return them, falling back to the old provider if the new provider does not have
• Multiple Data Sources: The multi-provider allows you to seamlessly combine many sources of flagging data, such as environment variables, local files, database values and SaaS hosted feature management systems.

Usage

import (
	"github.com/open-feature/go-sdk/openfeature"
	"github.com/open-feature/go-sdk/openfeature/multi"
	"github.com/open-feature/go-sdk/openfeature/memprovider"
)

mprovider, err := multi.NewProvider(
  multi.StrategyFirstMatch,
  multi.WithProvider("providerA", memprovider.NewInMemoryProvider(/*...*/)),
  multi.WithProvider("providerB", myCustomProvider),
)
if err != nil {
  return err
}

openfeature.SetNamedProviderAndWait("multiprovider", mprovider)

Strategies

There are three strategies that are defined by the spec and are available within this multi-provider implementation. In addition to the three provided strategies a custom strategy can be defined as well.

The three provided strategies are:

• First Match
• First Success
• Comparison

First Match Strategy

The first match strategy works by sequentially calling each provider until a valid result is returned. The first provider that returns a result will be used. It will try calling the next provider whenever it encounters a FLAG_NOT_FOUND error. However, if a provider returns an error other than FLAG_NOT_FOUND the provider will stop and return the default value along with setting the error details if a detailed request is issued.

First Success Strategy

The first success strategy also works by calling each provider sequentially. The first provider that returns a response with no errors is used. This differs from the first match strategy in that any provider raising an error will not halt calling the next provider if a successful result has not yet been encountered. If no provider provides a successful result the default value will be returned to the caller.

Comparison Strategy

The comparison strategy works by calling each provider in parallel. All results are collected from each provider and then the resolved results are compared to each other. If they all agree then that value is returned. If not a fallback provider can be specified to be executed instead or the default value will be returned. If a provider returns FLAG_NOT_FOUND that result will not be included in the comparison. If all providers return not found then the default value is returned. Finally, if any provider returns an error other than FLAG_NOT_FOUND the evaluation immediately stops and that error result is returned with the default value.

The fallback provider can be set using the WithFallbackProvider Option.

Special care must be taken when this strategy is used with ObjectEvaluation. If the resulting value is not a comparable type then the default result or fallback provider will always be used. In order to evaluate non comparable types a Comparator function must be provided as an Option to the constructor.

Custom Strategies

A custom strategy can be defined using the WithCustomStrategy Option along with the StrategyCustom constant. A custom strategy is defined by the following generic function signature:

StrategyFn[T FlagTypes] func(ctx context.Context, flag string, defaultValue T, flatCtx openfeature.FlattenedContext) openfeature.GenericResolutionDetail[T]

However, this doesn't provide any way to retrieve the providers! Therefore, there's the type StrategyConstructor that is called for you to close over the providers inside your StratetegyFn implementation.

type StrategyConstructor func(providers []*NamedProvider) StrategyFn[FlagTypes]

Build your strategy to wrap around the slice of providers

option := multi.WithCustomStrategy(func(providers []NamedProvider) StrategyFn[FlagTypes] {
	return func[T FlagTypes](ctx context.Context, flag string, defaultValue T, flatCtx openfeature.FlattenedContext) openfeature.GenericResolutionDetail[T] {
		// implementation
		// ...
    }
})

It is highly recommended to use the provided exposed functions to build your custom strategy. Specifically, the functions BuildDefaultResult & Evaluate are exposed for those implementing their own custom strategies.

The Evaluate method should be used for evaluating the result of a single NamedProvider. It determines the evaluation type via the type of the generic defaultVal parameter.

The BuildDefaultResult method should be called when an error is encountered or the strategy "fails" and needs to return the default result passed to one of the Evaluation methods of openfeature.FeatureProvider.

Options

The multi.NewProvider constructor implements the optional pattern for setting additional configuration.

General Options

WithLogger

Allows for providing a slog.Logger instance for internal logging of the multi-provider's evaluation processing for debugging purposes. By default, are logs are discarded unless this option is used.

WithCustomStrategy

Allows for setting a custom strategy function for the evaluation of providers. This must be used in conjunction with the StrategyCustom EvaluationStrategy parameter. The option itself takes a StrategyConstructor function, which is essentially a factory that allows the StrategyFn to wrap around a slice of NamedProvider instances.

WithGlobalHooks

Allows for setting global hooks for the multi-provider. These are openfeature.Hook implementations that affect all internal FeatureProvider instances.

WithProvider

Allows for registering a specific FeatureProvider instance under a unique provider name. Optional openfeature.Hook implementations may also be provided, which will execute only for this specific provider. This option can be used multiple times with unique provider names to register multiple providers. The order in which WithProvider options are provided determines the order in which the providers are registered and evaluated.

StrategyComparision specific options

There are two options specifically for usage with the StrategyComparision EvaluationStrategy. If these options are used with a different EvaluationStrategy they are ignored.

WithFallbackProvider

When the results are not in agreement with each other the fallback provider will be called. The result of this provider is what will be returned to the caller. If no fallback provider is set then the default value will be returned instead.

WithCustomComparator

When using ObjectEvaluation there are cases where the results are not able to be compared to each other by default. This happens if the returned type is not comparable. In that situation all the results are passed to the custom Comparator to evaluate if they are in agreement or not. If not provided and the return type is not comparable then either the fallback provider is used or the default value.